Chapter 5 – The Secret in the Oven

We left Marcus to guard the bedroom and hurried downstairs.

The guests had already been evacuated by security. The massive dining room was completely empty, the half-eaten extravagant meals left abandoned on the expensive china plates.

The engagement party was officially a disaster.

We entered the industrial-sized kitchen.

Rosa walked straight to the large commercial oven in the corner. She pulled open the heavy metal door and reached into the back.

She pulled out a rusted, dirt-covered steel lockbox.

It was about the size of a shoebox, heavily oxidized from years spent buried in the damp soil.

She set it on the stainless steel prep counter.

Nico stepped forward.

He slid the tiny brass key from his mother’s rosary into the rusted keyhole.

He turned it.

There was a stiff, metallic click.

He flipped the latches and opened the lid.

Inside, wrapped in layers of thick, waterproof oilcloth, was a stack of heavy parchment documents.

Nico carefully unwrapped them.

I saw the intricate borders and the official seals.

“The bearer bonds,” Nico breathed. “Twelve million dollars.”

But there was something else inside the box.

Beneath the stack of bonds was a small, sealed envelope and a worn leather journal.

Nico picked up the envelope.

His mother’s elegant handwriting was looped across the front.

For Nico. When the time is right.

Nico’s hands shook slightly as he broke the seal and pulled out a single sheet of paper.

He read it in silence.

As he read, the color slowly drained from his face.

“Nicky?” Rosa asked gently. “What does it say?”

Nico looked up. His eyes were wide with a mixture of shock and profound sadness.

“My mother didn’t bury this box to hide the money from my father,” he said quietly.

He looked at Rosa.

“She buried it to hide it from Victoria’s family.”

I frowned. “I don’t understand.”

Nico handed the letter to his father, who had insisted on walking downstairs with us.

“Twenty-seven years ago,” Nico explained, “Victoria’s father was a business partner to the Santoro family. He was the one who orchestrated the hit that killed my mother.”

The kitchen went dead silent.

Mr. Santoro closed his eyes, clutching the letter.

“We always suspected,” the old man whispered. “But we never had proof.”

“She found out about his plan,” Nico said, pointing to the leather journal in the box. “She wrote everything down in that diary. He wanted these bonds to fund his own operation. When she refused to hand them over, he arranged the car accident.”

Rosa gasped, covering her mouth.

“Before she died, she buried the box behind the cottage,” Nico continued. “And she gave Rosa the right to live there for the rest of her life.”

He looked at the elderly cook with deep reverence.

“Not just to protect you, Rosa. But to protect the evidence. Because she knew no one would ever suspect the sweet family cook was sleeping ten feet away from twelve million dollars and the proof to destroy the Ashford family.”

My mind was spinning.

Victoria hadn’t just been trying to steal money. She was trying to dig up the cottage to find the bonds and destroy the journal that proved her father murdered Nico’s mother.

That was why she wanted Rosa gone.

That was why she wanted Mr. Santoro locked away in a facility.

She needed total control of the property to erase her family’s sins.

“We have the journal,” Nico said, his voice hardening into pure steel. “I am going to hand this over to the federal prosecutor tomorrow. The Ashford family is finished.”

He looked at his father.

“Papa, I’m so sorry. I almost married the daughter of the man who killed Mom.”

Mr. Santoro reached out and pulled his son into a tight embrace.

“You didn’t know, Nicky. None of us did.”

They held each other for a long moment.

When Nico finally pulled away, he looked back into the rusted metal box.

There was one last object sitting at the very bottom.

He reached in and pulled it out.

It was a delicate silver bracelet.

A child’s bracelet.

Engraved with a tiny star and the date October 14th.

Nico frowned, staring at it.

“What is this?” he murmured. “My mother never had a bracelet like this.”

He turned it over in his hand.

Rosa stepped closer, looking at the silver jewelry.

Suddenly, she gasped.

She turned and looked directly at me.

“Sophie,” Rosa whispered.

I froze.

“What?” I asked.

Rosa pointed a trembling finger at the silver bracelet in Nico’s hand.

“Your father,” Rosa said, her voice shaking. “What is your father’s name?”

“Thomas,” I answered, completely bewildered. “Thomas Bennett.”

Nico looked at me.

Then he looked at the bracelet.

Then he opened the first page of his mother’s journal.

He read the first line aloud.

If anything happens to me, Thomas Bennett is the only man who knows the whole truth.

Share