Chapter 3 – The Bakery Behind His Name

Caroline pushed her chair back.

For a second, I thought she might leave.

Instead, she stood very still, one hand resting against the table to keep herself steady.

“You bought my building?”

Dominic looked at the notice.

“I invested in a property redevelopment project. Several properties, actually. I didn’t know your bakery was one of the tenants.”

Caroline gave a short laugh.

It wasn’t a pleasant sound.

“So you didn’t want my bakery to exist, but you didn’t even know it was mine?”

“Carrie, that’s not what happened.”

“Then tell me what did happen.”

Dominic looked toward Victoria.

She seemed to have recovered some of her composure.

“North Pier acquired the property as part of a neighborhood restoration project,” she said. “The building has structural issues. Dominic approved the investment because we believed the block could support more profitable businesses.”

“More profitable than what?” Caroline asked.

“Small retail tenants.”

“Like bakeries.”

“Caroline, don’t make this personal.”

Caroline stared at her.

“You took the place where my mother learned to bake. How much more personal would you like it?”

Dominic looked up.

“Your mother?”

Caroline turned toward him.

“Mom worked there when she was seventeen. Before she met you.”

He said nothing.

“She used to tell me about the old brick ovens and the woman who taught her how to make frosting without a mixer.”

Dominic’s expression softened with recognition.

“Mrs. Callahan.”

Caroline nodded.

“You remember.”

“Of course I remember.”

“Then you know why I wanted that building.”

He looked down at the notice.

“Yes.”

Caroline’s voice was very quiet.

“Then why did I have to explain it to you?”

That question seemed to hurt him more than the accusations.

He had no good answer.

Victoria took advantage of the silence.

“Dominic, the purchase was a sound investment. The building needs major renovations. The commercial plan was approved weeks ago.”

“What plan?”

“The one you signed.”

“I approved a preliminary development budget.”

“And the conversion drawings.”

Dominic studied her.

“Conversion to what?”

Victoria hesitated.

“A hospitality space.”

“What kind?”

“A boutique event venue. Private tastings, bridal consultations, small receptions.”

Caroline looked toward the enormous birthday cake.

Then at the white roses surrounding the table.

She laughed once, almost under her breath.

“You’re turning my bakery into a wedding showroom.”

Victoria’s expression hardened.

“The property was never yours, Caroline. You rented it.”

“For five years.”

“Subject to the terms of your lease.”

“A lease I haven’t broken.”

Dominic stood.

“Victoria, we’ll discuss the project tomorrow. Tonight, nobody is canceling anything.”

“The redevelopment schedule doesn’t work that way.”

“Then the schedule changes.”

She stared at him.

“You cannot overturn a business decision simply because Caroline is upset.”

Dominic looked at his daughter.

“She’s not upset because she didn’t get something she wanted. She’s upset because someone took something she already had.”

That silenced Victoria.

But Caroline didn’t look relieved.

She folded the notice again.

“I don’t want you to buy me another bakery.”

“I haven’t offered.”

“Not yet.”

She gave him a tired smile.

“I know how this works, Dad. You see a problem, and you make somebody handle it.”

Dominic looked genuinely wounded.

But Caroline continued.

“I don’t want a building handed to me because I’m your daughter. I want the lease I signed to mean something.”

I had never heard anyone speak to Dominic Moretti quite like that.

He listened.

Then nodded.

“That’s fair.”

Victoria pushed back her chair.

“Can we please remember that this is supposed to be a celebration?”

Dominic glanced at the six-tier cake.

“I’m beginning to understand whose celebration it was.”

Victoria flinched.

For the first time, I wondered whether beneath her perfect appearance there was something less simple than cruelty.

She had spent months arranging this evening.

Every napkin, every flower, every expensive glass had been chosen to create an image of the family she expected to marry into.

And Caroline, with a homemade cake and a cheap cardigan, had disturbed that image without even trying.

But Victoria had done more than protect a dinner party.

She had helped keep a daughter away from her father.

And now the daughter’s livelihood was threatened by a company Victoria had been managing.

I couldn’t convince myself those things were unrelated.

Dominic seemed to have reached the same uncomfortable possibility.

“Victoria, when did you first see the tenant list for the Armitage property?”

“Months ago.”

“Was Caroline’s name on it?”

“I don’t memorize every tenant in your portfolio.”

“That’s not what I asked.”

Victoria looked at Caroline.

“Her lease was filed under Sunday Table Bakery. There was no reason for me to associate it with her.”

Caroline blinked.

“Sunday Table?”

“Yes. That’s your business name, isn’t it?”

“It is.”

Something passed over Caroline’s face.

Not anger this time.

Recognition.

She turned toward her father.

“Dad, remember the blue notebook Mom kept in the kitchen?”

He frowned.

“The recipe book?”

Caroline nodded.

“She wrote ‘Sunday Table’ on the inside cover years before she died. She said someday she’d like a little bakery where nobody had to eat alone.”

Dominic looked toward Victoria.

Caroline continued.

“I told Victoria that story when I sent the invitation to my opening.”

Victoria went completely still.

Caroline reached into her purse again.

This time she removed a cream-colored envelope.

“I sent two invitations,” she said. “One for Dad. One for Victoria.”

She placed the envelope on the table.

“Victoria mailed hers back.”

Dominic stared at it.

Across the front, in precise black handwriting, were four words.

Return to sender. Unwelcome here.

Caroline looked at Victoria.

“And now you’re telling me you didn’t know the bakery was mine?”

Share